fix(code-runtime-python): verify union<->roster both ways, stop pycache writes, refresh metering prose

Address the latest review round:

- WireFrameShapesCoverUnions checked only union ⊆ roster, so removing a frame
  from a message union (e.g. dropping ReplyErr from ReplyMessage) left the check
  true while the public TS union diverged from the wire. Replace it with a
  bidirectional equivalence between MessageFrames and the roster's message-frame
  value types (nested Namespace/ErrorClass/DoneErrorField excluded): both a frame
  added to a union without a roster entry and a frame removed from a union now
  fail typecheck (both verified).
- The mirror e2e's python3 probes imported protocol.py without -B, writing
  py/__pycache__/*.pyc into the (un-ignored) source tree. Add -B to both.
- Refresh the metering prose (checkDoneValue JSDoc + README both sides + Agent
  Note both sides): the incremental-work list no longer says "per-key
  JSON.stringify" now that jsonStringBytesUpTo scans without stringifying;
  re-record the README and Agent Note i18n pairings.
This commit is contained in:
Chinesezjc
2026-08-07 13:27:54 +08:00
parent f9ab1edc68
commit 4674d8fa92
8 changed files with 38 additions and 25 deletions
@@ -2,5 +2,5 @@
# side as of the last confirmed-consistent state. Both languages carry equal authority;
# after editing either side, bring the other along and re-record with:
# pnpm run verify-translation-pairing --write packages/code-runtime/code-runtime-python/README.md
README.md: d0491c478d04a8436199bc23fd79917e8c019b1c
README.zh.md: 63d7d38ee05b561e60a3adf387c5c1292c37a7a2
README.md: 606d153eb899925ae274133b3728d317607a17e2
README.zh.md: f4387d6b20994781b8e64d31da7319badb56aacd
@@ -12,7 +12,7 @@ The host and the CPython subprocess exchange a versionless, JSON-lines protocol
- **fd 3, not stdout** — Node pins the channel positionally with `stdio: ['pipe','pipe','pipe','pipe']`; the Python bootstrap reads the same `PROTOCOL_FD` constant. JSON-lines framing.
- **Host treats every inbound frame as hostile** — model code has full access to fd 3 and can post anything through it, so `validateChildFrame` shape-validates and REBUILDS each frame before the host reads it: forged extra fields never ride along, a non-number call id can never be echoed into a reply, and junk drops to `undefined` rather than throwing in the host's message handler. The Python side trusts host replies (the host is not model-controlled).
- **Lossless-JSON crossing** — completion values and binding arguments cross as exact JSON. `encodeJsonPlain` serializes a `JSON.parse`-produced value without recursion, so a deep value below the byte budget crosses intact instead of dying on `JSON.stringify`'s stack limit; `checkDoneValue` meters a forged completion value's byte length AND number losslessness in one traversal that rejects an over-budget payload before the incremental work it would add (escaped-string copy, enqueued children, per-key `JSON.stringify`) — the frame's own width is already parsed and capped upstream by the host's fd-3 receive buffer, not re-bounded here; `hasUnsafeIntegerToken` reads the raw frame text to catch an integer token that `JSON.parse` would silently round; `hasNonLosslessNumber` rejects a non-finite or negative-zero number in unbounded `call.args`. Beyond-safe-range integral doubles serialize through `BigInt` digits so the exact integer crosses, not the rounded `String()` form.
- **Lossless-JSON crossing** — completion values and binding arguments cross as exact JSON. `encodeJsonPlain` serializes a `JSON.parse`-produced value without recursion, so a deep value below the byte budget crosses intact instead of dying on `JSON.stringify`'s stack limit; `checkDoneValue` meters a forged completion value's byte length AND number losslessness in one traversal that rejects an over-budget payload before the incremental work it would add (a non-allocating escaped-size scan, then enqueued children) — the frame's own width is already parsed and capped upstream by the host's fd-3 receive buffer, not re-bounded here; `hasUnsafeIntegerToken` reads the raw frame text to catch an integer token that `JSON.parse` would silently round; `hasNonLosslessNumber` rejects a non-finite or negative-zero number in unbounded `call.args`. Beyond-safe-range integral doubles serialize through `BigInt` digits so the exact integer crosses, not the rounded `String()` form.
- **Shared truncation marker** — `logTruncationMarker(maxBytes)` produces byte-identical text on both sides, so a truncated log run reads the same however the cap was hit. The `log` frame's `truncated` flag distinguishes the child ledger's own marker from program output.
## Model Experience
@@ -12,7 +12,7 @@ host 与 CPython 子进程在子进程的 fd 3 上交换一个无版本号的 JS
- **fd 3,而非 stdout** —— Node 通过 `stdio: ['pipe','pipe','pipe','pipe']` 按位置钉住通道;Python bootstrap 读取相同的 `PROTOCOL_FD` 常量。JSON-lines 帧。
- **host 把每个入站帧当作敌意输入** —— 模型代码对 fd 3 有完全访问权、可通过它发送任意内容,所以 `validateChildFrame` 在 host 读取前对每个帧做形状校验并重建:伪造的额外字段绝不随行,非数字的 call id 绝不会被回显进 reply,垃圾降为 `undefined` 被丢弃,而不是在 host 的 message handler 里抛错。Python 侧信任 host 回复(host 不受模型控制)。
- **lossless-JSON 穿越** —— 完成值与 binding 参数以精确 JSON 穿越。`encodeJsonPlain` 无递归地序列化一个 `JSON.parse` 产出的值,使低于字节预算的深层值能完整穿越,而不是死在 `JSON.stringify` 的栈限制上;`checkDoneValue` 在一次遍历中同时计量伪造完成值的字节长度与数字无损性,在它本会新增的增量工作之前就拒绝超预算 payload(转义串副本、入栈子节点、逐 key 的 `JSON.stringify`)——帧自身的宽度已被上游 `JSON.parse` 支付、由 host 的 fd-3 接收缓冲封顶,并非在此重新约束;`hasUnsafeIntegerToken` 读取原始帧文本,捕获 `JSON.parse` 会静默舍入的整数 token`hasNonLosslessNumber` 拒绝无字节上限的 `call.args` 中的非有限数或负零。超出安全范围的整数型 double 通过 `BigInt` 数字序列化,穿越的是精确整数而非 `String()` 的舍入形式。
- **lossless-JSON 穿越** —— 完成值与 binding 参数以精确 JSON 穿越。`encodeJsonPlain` 无递归地序列化一个 `JSON.parse` 产出的值,使低于字节预算的深层值能完整穿越,而不是死在 `JSON.stringify` 的栈限制上;`checkDoneValue` 在一次遍历中同时计量伪造完成值的字节长度与数字无损性,在它本会新增的增量工作之前就拒绝超预算 payload(先做非分配的转义尺寸扫描,再入栈子节点)——帧自身的宽度已被上游 `JSON.parse` 支付、由 host 的 fd-3 接收缓冲封顶,并非在此重新约束;`hasUnsafeIntegerToken` 读取原始帧文本,捕获 `JSON.parse` 会静默舍入的整数 token`hasNonLosslessNumber` 拒绝无字节上限的 `call.args` 中的非有限数或负零。超出安全范围的整数型 double 通过 `BigInt` 数字序列化,穿越的是精确整数而非 `String()` 的舍入形式。
- **共享截断标记** —— `logTruncationMarker(maxBytes)` 在两侧产出逐字节一致的文本,使被截断的日志运行无论从哪侧触达上限都读起来一致。`log` 帧的 `truncated` 标志把子进程 ledger 自身的标记与程序输出区分开。
## Model Experience
@@ -185,20 +185,32 @@ interface WireFrameShapes {
}
/**
* Compile-time proof that {@link WireFrameShapes} lists every frame carried on a
* message union: the union of the frame types (`ChildToHost`, the reply
* variants, and the host-to-child boot/run frames) must be assignable to the
* union of the roster's value types. Adding a frame to a union without a
* `WireFrameShapes` entry makes this alias `false`, so the assignment below
* fails to compile — closing the whole-frame drift the field-level binding
* alone could not see. Nested shapes (`Namespace`, `ErrorClass`,
* `DoneErrorField`) are not union members; they are covered by the roles
* `satisfies` and the mirror e2e's roster comparison.
* The frames carried on a message union: everything the host and child send as
* a top-level frame (`ChildToHost`, the two reply variants, and the host→child
* boot/run frames). The nested shapes `Namespace`, `ErrorClass`, and
* `DoneErrorField` are fields of other frames, not frames themselves, so they
* are excluded here and covered only by the roles `satisfies` and the mirror e2e.
*/
type WireFrameShapesCoverUnions =
[ChildToHost | ReplyMessage | BootMessage | RunMessage] extends [WireFrameShapes[keyof WireFrameShapes]] ? true : false
const _wireFrameShapesCoverUnions: WireFrameShapesCoverUnions = true
void _wireFrameShapesCoverUnions
type MessageFrames = ChildToHost | ReplyMessage | BootMessage | RunMessage
/** The roster's value types minus the three nested (non-frame) shapes. */
type RosterMessageFrames = Exclude<WireFrameShapes[keyof WireFrameShapes], Namespace | ErrorClass | DoneErrorField>
/**
* Compile-time proof that {@link WireFrameShapes}'s message-frame entries are
* EXACTLY the frames on the message unions — checked BOTH directions. Forward
* (`MessageFrames extends RosterMessageFrames`) catches a frame added to a union
* without a roster entry; reverse (`RosterMessageFrames extends MessageFrames`)
* catches a frame removed from a union while the roster still lists it (e.g.
* dropping `ReplyErr` from `ReplyMessage`). Either divergence makes an alias
* `false`, failing the assignment below. Type-only; the `const`s emit nothing
* meaningful at runtime.
*/
type UnionCoversRoster = [MessageFrames] extends [RosterMessageFrames] ? true : false
type RosterCoversUnion = [RosterMessageFrames] extends [MessageFrames] ? true : false
const _unionCoversRoster: UnionCoversRoster = true
const _rosterCoversUnion: RosterCoversUnion = true
void _unionCoversRoster
void _rosterCoversUnion
/**
* Each frame's wire fields tagged by required/optional, keyed by field name so
@@ -375,8 +387,9 @@ function jsonStringBytesUpTo(text: string, maxBytes: number): number | undefined
* Meter a `JSON.parse`-produced done value's compact-JSON byte length AND its
* number losslessness in one traversal, stopping the instant `maxBytes` is
* crossed. This bounds the INCREMENTAL allocation the check itself would add on
* top of the already-parsed value — the escaped-string copy, the enqueued
* children, the per-key `JSON.stringify` — not the parse that produced `value`.
* top of the already-parsed value — the enqueued children (and, in the previous
* implementation, an escaped-string copy that {@link jsonStringBytesUpTo} now
* avoids) — not the parse that produced `value`.
* That upstream width is bounded separately, by the host-side cap on inbound
* fd-3 frame size before `JSON.parse` runs (owned by the runtime that reads the
* channel), so `value` cannot be arbitrarily large when it reaches here, while
@@ -45,7 +45,7 @@ describe.skipIf(!python3Available)('protocol.py mirrors protocol.ts at runtime',
' "markers": [log_truncation_marker(b) for b in budgets],',
'}))',
].join('\n')
const { stdout } = await execFileAsync('python3', ['-I', '-c', probe])
const { stdout } = await execFileAsync('python3', ['-I', '-B', '-c', probe])
const seen = JSON.parse(stdout) as { fd: number; markers: string[] }
// Assert against the TS-side PROTOCOL_FD export (the value the host wires),
// not a bare literal, so a drift on either side of the wire is caught here.
@@ -75,7 +75,7 @@ describe.skipIf(!python3Available)('protocol.py mirrors protocol.ts at runtime',
+ ' if not n.startswith("_") and hasattr(v, "__required_keys__")}',
'print(json.dumps(frames))',
].join('\n')
const { stdout } = await execFileAsync('python3', ['-I', '-c', probe])
const { stdout } = await execFileAsync('python3', ['-I', '-B', '-c', probe])
const seen = JSON.parse(stdout) as Record<string, { required: string[]; optional: string[] }>
// Normalize the TS source of truth to the same sorted shape Python reports.
const expected = Object.fromEntries(